Coconut Strawberry Cream and Orange Creamsicle Jello Pudding

coconut strawberry cream and orange creamsicle jello puddingJELLO MANIA


We have been creating new recipes in the Don kitchen and today I am sharing one that I call Strawberry and Orange Creamsicle Jello Pudding.

My kids dive in when I make this so it doesn’t last very long around our house.

Coming up with Jello dessert ideas may prove to be tough because most people stick to the box directions.

The catch is if you understand how to make basic Jello it’s easy to manipulate the recipe to create something you can call your own.

Sometimes it takes trial and error but you won’t have to worry about that today. I’ve perfected my Jello recipe for you.

Jello ingredients typically calls for the Jello crystals and water, it’s that simple to make. Today I’m going to show you how you can create Jello mania in your home. Your friends will ask you for your secret recipe.

Some of the top Jello flavours on the market today are Cherry, Lime, Strawberry, Berry Blue, Orange, Lemon, Grape and Raspberry just to name a few.


History of Jello


Jello or jelly as the UK calls it, is something we would make special on birthdays because you can’t have ice-cream unless there is Jello/Jelly. In Canada you can’t have cake without ice-cream so there are slight differences between country favourites but they both are as delicious.

My mum always argues with me and says nope cream is the best instead of ice-cream. No matter what your favourite Jello flavour is this recipe will blow you away.

Jello desserts have been around since the late 1800’s in New York when it was first invented when gelatin was mixed with fruit flavours and dubbed Jello.

Did you know?

The gelatinous aspect of the food made it a popular choice among mothers when their children were suffering from diarrhea. In fact, doctors still recommend serving Jell-O water (that is, unhardened Jell-O) to children suffering from loose stools.

I had coconut milk left over from my easy chicken curry in a hurry we made last night so not to waste it we are having it mixed into this delicious Jello dessert.

This Jello dessert is great for parties, pot-lucks and those rainy days (or tornadoes with us yesterday) which is easy to make and no cooking or ovens required to be turned on. This makes this Jello recipe the perfect summer treat especially on those hot days.

The simplicity of this Jello recipe requires just mixing it together without missing any of the crucial steps. The hard part is waiting so what I tend to do is let it set overnight while I’m sleeping. I like Jello layers with my Jello creamsicle dessert using different flavours or mix it half and half which looks prettier.

This creamsicle jello is even a great recipe for a baby shower, wedding shower or birthday party.

Quick Tip: When you are mixing the Jello and hot water, sprinkle the Jello crystals as you are stirring as I have found when you just pour the whole packet in it doesn’t dissolve and you are left with crystals. It’s the same when I have put the Jello in first and then added the water.


How to make Creamsicle Jello Pudding Dessert


strawberry cream and orange creamsicle jello pudding

  • Prep time – 10 mins
  • Fridge time – overnight or until it sets
5.0 from 1 reviews
Strawberry and Orange Creamsicle Jello Pudding
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
If you are a fan of creamsicle ice-cream and jello you will love this mixture that i created using traditional jello flavours, coconut and condensed milks. It's easy and takes overnight to set.
Recipe type: Dessert
Serves: 4
  • 2 packs Jello (used strawberry and orange)
  • 1 can condensed milk (place in fridge night before)
  • 1 cup coconut milk (place in fridge night before)
  • 2 tablespoons sweetened coconut
  • 2 cups hot water
  1. First get the kettle on and boil your water as per the instructions on the back of the jello pack.
  2. Using a large bowl take the first pack of jello and follow the first step by adding it to the hot water. I use strawberry for my first one as this will become your strawberry coconut creamsicle flavour. Mix until dissolved.
  3. Now instead of adding cold water add the coconut milk into the strawberry jello and stir.
  4. Once combined sprinkle the coconut into the jello. Do not mix it in as it will sink to the bottom just sprinkle it.
  5. Now leave this to set slightly for at least 2hrs or until it it slightly set on top.
  6. Then comes the second packet orange, which is going to become your creamsicle flavour.
  7. This time in a large jug mix the 1 cup of hot water and jello.
  8. Now once it had dissolved mix in the can of condensed milk.
  9. Take out the the bowl with the first jello in it and gentle pour it over the top.
  10. Place the big bowl back in the fridge and either leave overnight or if you do this first thing in the morning it should be set by the time you have supper in the evening.

To finish this off this Jello pudding why not decorate with fresh fruit and some whipped cream which my family loves. I like my jello creamsicle pudding without anything other than a little sorbet depending on the flavour.

This is truly a mix your own Jello flavour recipe. The recipe can be done so many ways that I have even created a rainbow flavour mixing just jello and creamsicle flavours. Whichever Jello flavours you choose enjoy!

Nicky x

Subscribe to Canadian Budget Binder so you get my daily email and Follow me on all the popular Social Media Outlets. Get every recipe from Canadian Budget Binder> Check out my new Free Recipe Index.

If you like FREE then click this link for my FREE Excel Budget Spreadsheet and lists. Check out my new Ultimate Grocery Shopping Guide.

Related articles
Nicola Don
Nicola Don was born in Aberdeen Scotland and lived most of her years in Ellon Aberdeenshire ,Scotland. She is a stay at home mom of three kids to whom she adores and a passionate mom chef at heart. Nicola has been married for 16 years to a wonderful husband. Her family moved from the UK 8 years ago to Ste Anne MB, Canada where they are now permanent residents. Nicola loves to cook and experiment with flavours while creating recipes. She aims to give her family the best food and variety of tastes from all over the world while using fresh ingredients with-in her grocery budget.


  1. Jello pudding fascinates me and it is really one of my favorites. Nicola, I found a trivia about Jello. There are some pretty weird alternative uses for Jell-O. It can be sprinkled over cat litter, used as a hair or clothing dye, made into a finger paint, or used as an aid for ridding bathrooms of soap scum. There are surely lot more!

  2. Christine Weadick says:

    This looks very interesting and fudg-able!! I’ll have to look over the Jello packs next time they come on sale and see what other combinations I can think of!! I do enjoy cherry flavour …… I never thought of using some kind of milk with jello but I have used the powder to colours and flavour frosting for cookies. Plenty to think about in the grocery store now..Thanks Nicola!!!!

    • Nicola Don says:

      christine we love this here and as you say so easy to mix up different flavours. Even I between the layers I have put fruit too just so it’s interesting. Can’t wait to hear what you come up with

Add Your Comment


Rate this recipe:  

%d bloggers like this: