The Perfect Vanilla Ice-Cream Sandwich (Low-Carb)




My wife was in the mood for something sweet the other night and kept bugging me to help her create a vanilla ice-cream sandwich treat for the summer.

I got to work making the cookie base for the vanilla ice-cream sandwich which wasn’t easy and took me a few tries. The tender cookies don’t take long to make however it’s the batter consistency that you need to watch out for. The cookie batter should look frothy and not dense.

When I eat an ice-cream sandwich I don’t want to have a hard cookie base. You expect to bite into an ice-cream sandwich where your teeth sink through the soft cookie, into the ice-cream and again through another cookie. I am not a fan of the ice-cream sandwich with the hard cookie as I find the ice-cream squashes out too easily and a big mess is born.

Don’t get me wrong they taste good and I wouldn’t turn one down but for my wife I knew that being on a low-carb diet that most cookies that we create do come out of the oven moist. The reason for the moist cookie is because we aren’t using all-purpose flour, rather we use coconut flour, flax-seed and protein powder.

With coconut flour you need to be cautious as it soaks up moisture like a mushroom. If you use too much you will have a dry cookie that falls apart. Never ever over-bake any cookie or it will be hard as a rock. I’d rather under-bake it and let it cook on the baking sheet.

Since we don’t use granulated sugar in any low-carb recipes that we create we substitute with Stevia Erythritol which sweetens without the calories. I have a coffee grinder so I powder up what I need when I bake. It is a natural product that tastes and looks just like sugar with no side-effects like some other sweeteners cause. The only downfall is that it can be a bit pricey. It is available at the Bulk Barn in Canada.

These particular cookies are a flavoured Almond Coffee Base cookie which I’m telling you is amazing. It pairs so nice with the homemade ice-cream that it’s hard to not go back to grab another one. My wife ended up dividing the batch 2 for her and 2 for me.

This recipe makes 6 large cookies which I shaped by hand to get them as square as I could. Once the cookies were cool and filled with ice-cream I trimmed them so they would be square like a traditional vanilla ice-cream sandwich. The extra trimmings were put in a bowl with a couple of scoops of the ice-cream. That didn’t last long as my wife was purring with delight. She said it was the best treat she’s eaten in a long while.  YES!!

amaretto coffee cookie trimmings with low carb no churn vanilla ice-cream


Homemade N0-Churn Vanilla Keto Ice-Cream


homemade no churn vanilla keto ice-cream low-carb

I like to think of myself as pretty good in the kitchen however when it comes to creating no-churn vanilla ket0 Ice-cream I thought I better check in with the pros. The homemade no-churn vanilla keto ice-cream recipe which is low-carb/primal that I used was adapted from a recipe Martina created over at The Keto Diet Blog.

Honestly, I was a bit reluctant to make it on my own because I didn’t have the time to mess up and learn from my mistakes and the ingredients are pricey. So, unless you know what you are doing with ice-cream making especially when it involves raw eggs leave it to someone who has tested it to perfection.

One look at Martina’s ice-cream and you will be drooling and let me tell you it tastes as good as it looks. Below are the ingredients you will need to make her homemade no-churn vanilla keto ice-cream. Click the link to get the full instructions for the recipe including step by step photos. It’s easy to make.

I had about 2-3 cups leftover after filling the vanilla ice-cream sandwiches so I just froze it and the wife ate it for dessert. In each sandwich I put 3 small ice-cream scoops in each cookie equal to 1/2 cup or approximately 1.2 net carbs. The scoop was a bit bigger than a melon ball scoop.


Ingredients (makes 6 servings):


  • 4 large eggs, separated
  • ¼ tsp cream of tartar
  • ½ cup Erythritol or Swerve, powdered or other healthy low-carb sweetener from this list
  • 1 ¼ cups heavy whipping cream or coconut milk for dairy-free (300 ml / 1.1 fl oz)
  • 1 tbsp sugar-free vanilla extract (you can make your own)
  • Optional: 1 tsp vanilla bean powder for more vanilla taste

For every 2 scoops or 1 cup the net carbs are 2.3 grams which is pretty good for this recipe considering we don’t use 2 scoops in each vanilla ice-cream sandwich. I left the ice-cream in the freezer for 3 hours before I pulled it out to see if I could scoop it onto a cookie. I didn’t want it to be too soft or too hard, but just right.

Keep in mind once you wrap the vanilla ice-cream sandwiches in parchment paper or wax paper to freeze them individually they will harden up again which is what you want. Before you eat one take it out and let it sit for a few minutes if you like your vanilla ice-cream sandwich soft but if not tuck in right away.

Here is a picture of the vanilla keto ice-cream that I made for this recipe. If you’re not familiar with the Keto-Diet Ruled Me explains it quite well with their Beginners Guide to the Keto Diet.


How to make a Vanilla Ice-Cream Sandwich


Vanilla ice-cream sandwich low-carb

The Perfect Vanilla Ice-Cream Sandwich (Low-Carb)
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
If you're in the mood for a low-carb dessert this summer try your hand at making this easy homemade vanilla ice-cream sandwich.
Recipe type: Low Carb Dessert
Serves: 6
  • For the No-Churn Vanilla Ice-cream see the link in the above blog post.
  • Amaretto Coffee Sandwich Cookies
  • 1 large egg
  • 2 tablespoons peanut butter (just peanuts) no sugar or other additives
  • 2 tablespoons almond butter
  • 1 teaspoon Almond Extract
  • 1 teaspoon Pure Vanilla Extract
  • 1 tablespoon instant coffee mixed with 1 tablespoon hot boiling water and 1 tablespoon erythritol powder (mix and set aside to cool)
  • 4 tablespoons of powdered erythritol
  • 2½ tablespoons coconut flour
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla protein powder (low-carb as you can get)
  • 1 teaspoon ground flax-seed
  • 1 tablespoon whipping cream 35%
  • ¼ teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 tablespoon of good 100% cocoa powder
  1. In a microwave bowl add your peanut butter and almond butter and soften for about 15 seconds, then mix.
  2. Let cool for about 1-2 minutes then add in your vanilla extract and almond extract
  3. Add in your large egg and cooled instant coffee mixture then mix to combine
  4. Add in your powdered erythritol
  5. Add in your cocoa, coconut flour, flax seed and protein powder, baking soda, baking powder and whipping cream.
  6. Mix until combined and frothy
  7. Put in the refrigerator for about 10 minutes
  8. Pre-heat your oven to 350 degrees
  9. Line your baking sheet with a silpat or baking spray (i did not test using spray)
  10. Take a large ice-cream scoop size amount of the batter and put it on the baking sheet. With a spatula work the batter into a square. Do this for the next 5 cookies and make sure they are all even in size and spaced out as they will grow. You want them to be a bit bigger as you will trim them to perfection when they are done.
  11. When baked remove from oven and let cool completely.
  12. Once your ice-cream has been in the freezer for 3 hours test to see if you can scoop it where it's not runny but no too hard. Add 2-3 little ice-cream scoops of the ice-cream onto one cookie, spread it so it's even and top with another cookie. Put them into the freezer immediately on a tray or in a container to freeze. I'd let them freezer for at least 2 hours.
  13. Once frozen remove the ice-cream sandwiches and trim them so they are nice and even. Don't throw out the trimmings as you can enjoy them with the leftover ice-cream you have. Any leftover ice-cream can be frozen for up to 2 days.

It looks like it will be lots of work but it’s not that bad and they taste delicious. Once they are frozen you can wrap them if you like or just eat them all in one go. Ha, just kidding.

Nutrition Info:

Total Net Carbs Per Ice-cream Sandwich = 3.48g 2 cookies +1.2g ice-cream=4.68g net carbs in each. Keep in mind these are a fair size so you can cut them in half to make 12 or bake your sandwich cookies smaller. Your choice.

Enjoy and if you like this recipe please consider leaving a comment and rating this recipe.


Please share this recipe with your friends if you think they might like it and please leave a review and tell me what you think.

Enter your email address on the home page to SUBSCRIBE to my blog. Once you subscribe you will be sent an email from me immediately which you need to open and approve the subscription in order to start receiving my daily blog post.

Note: Check your Junk Mail if you don’t see it or email me to check into your subscription status.

If you like FREE then click this link for my FREE Excel Budget Spreadsheet and lists. Check out my new Free Recipe Index Plus catch up on all the ways to save money in our Free Ultimate Grocery Shopping Guide.

Related articles

Mr. CBB who was born and raised in the United Kingdom, moved to Canada where he is now a permanent resident. He is also a father to a very active 3 year old boy which keeps him young at heart. He bought his first house at the age of 21 in the UK after graduating University and his second at age 24. Mrs. CBB bought her first house at the age of 30. Both Mr.CBB and his wife are 40-ish year-old finance lovers who accomplished debt freedom before the age of 40. Canadian Budget Binder is a fun, family-friendly place where he shares their financial journey with his readers and hopes to learn about theirs. No silver-spoon just hard work and perseverance. Welcome to Canadian Budget Binder! You've got this!


  1. What a great idea! These look amazing! Thank you for including my ice-cream recipe 🙂

Add Your Comment


Rate this recipe:  

%d bloggers like this: