ITALIAN LEMON COOKIES FOR EASTER, CHRISTMAS, WEDDINGS AND ARE THE PERFECT DUNKING COOKIE
Soft Italian Lemon cookies with a lemon glaze and coloured sprinkles are a staple in just about every Italian family particularly those who hail from Southern Italy.
Does dunking Italian Anginetti cookies in your morning coffee sound familiar?
It probably does if you’re Italian but for those who haven’t you should try it.
I promise you these cookies are one of the best Italian cookies to dunk and I’ve had many growing up in an Italian neighbourhood.
With Easter (Pasqua-Italian) around the corner, I thought you’d all like to try something a bit different for your Easter dessert or before, after and in-between meals.
You can pretty much eat these Anginetti Italian lemon cookies all day (at least I can).
In my teens, I would visit my Italian friend almost daily to hang out and play or swoon over the boys.
Her mother would always have these amazing iced Italian cookies that I would drool over.
It was like living in a palace and I was jealous because all I got were Oreos from a bag.
These Italian cookies with sprinkles on top were big business especially for breakfast alongside a cup of coffee for dunking (especially after a night out at the club).
Just about every holiday or special occasion I was invited to with the family you could always bet on there being what became one of my favourite cookies, Italian lemon cookies.
I pretty much wiped the plate clean when no one was looking but they always knew who the cookie monster was.
When I asked if these Italian cookies had a traditional name I was told there were many.
The reason is that each region in Italy name their food differently even though it’s similar.
I wanted to give these cookies a shot and bake them for my family and friends with Mr.CBB.
Baking Italian Lemon Cookies With Nonna
After much research, I realized that the best person to ask for the recipe was my friend’s mother.
She is now in her 60’s and an Italian Nonna (grandmother) to 5 grandchildren.
Everyone just calls her Nonna so that’s what I do as well.
Recently when I went for a visit I asked if Nonna could make me those Italian lemon cookies.
The deal was that if she made the Italian Lemon Cookies then I would bring a batch of our chocolate peanut butter balls.
While I came prepared with my chocolate peanut butter balls Nonna wanted to make the Italian lemon cookies with me so I could learn.
It was quite the experience and far easier than I thought they would be to magic.
In fact, these Italian Lemon Cookies are so easy and simple to switch-up flavours for variations.
When I was younger these cookies were unique to me as some were round, oblong, knotted or even braided.
Italian lemon cookies are comparable to sinking your teeth into a dense yet soft cookie with a hint of sugar coming from the glaze and coloured sprinkles.
These Italian lemon cookies are not overly sweet and the variety of Anginetti flavours always keeps them interesting.
You never knew what flavour you would get since Nonna piled them all onto a tiered cookie display in the middle of the table on top of a knitted doily.
Flavours of Anginetti Italian Cookies
Italian Anginetti cookies take on many faces but they all taste similar depending on added extract flavours.
Keep in mind that some Italian families may offer a certain variety based on the celebration as well.
Over Easter, you may find the lemon cookies are popular where Christmas cookies will be anise or amaretti flavour.
However, it all depends on the Italian family of what traditional cookies they’ve adopted over the years.
Anginetti Italian lemon cookies can also be flavoured with;
We typically buy Everland or Lorann oils and flavours which offer excellent taste and affordable prices.
- Anise Extract
- Vanilla Extract
- Orange zest
- Vanilla, Orange, and Lemon named Fiori di Sicilia extract but without the floral essences.
Italians use this to flavour Panettone, ice-cream, cakes, cookies, meringues, and sweetbreads.
You might even find some of these Italian drop cookies offer lemon or orange rind for an even more powerful flavour.
Alternate Names For Italian Lemon Cookies
Below are many of the names you may encounter just in case someone offers you a similar cookie.
- Italian lemon cookies
- Italian lemon knot cookies
- Italian wedding cookies
- Lemon Iced Cookies
- Italian Easter Cookies
- Italian Christmas Cookies
- Anginetti Cookies
- Italian Taralli Cookies
- Taralli Dolci Di Pasqua
- Italian lemon cookies
- Italian lemon drop cookies
How to make Italian Lemon Cookies (Anginetti)
I would have loved to add the Fiori di Sicilia however we don’t have that in our pantry as I have yet to find it.
However, I may just have to order it online and have it shipped to the house.
What I did do is create my own Fiori di Sicilia flavour without the orange for these Italian lemon cookies.
I used a mix of pure vanilla extract, lemon oil, and lemon extract to boost the flavour and fragrance of the cookie.
This recipe makes about 30-35 medium-sized cookies big enough to dunk and fit in your mouth.
If you make them smaller or larger you will end up with a different number.
- Lemon Cookie Ingredients
- 6 large eggs
- 5 cups all-purpose flour
- 2 tablespoons baking powder
- 1/2 pound unsalted butter softened
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
- 2 teaspoons lemon extract or 3 teaspoons pure lemon juice
- 3 drops of lemon oil
- 2 tablespoons lemon rind (optional)
- Lemon Glaze
- 1lb bag icing sugar or confectioner’s sugar
- 2 teaspoons lemon extract or 3 without the lemon oil
- 3 drops of lemon oil
- Add milk starting with a tablespoon until desired consistency. You can always add but you can’t take away. I used 4 tablespoons in total.
- Colourful sprinkles
- In a large bowl sift your dry ingredients- flour, salt, baking powder
- In a stand mixer add the butter, sugar- mix until fluffy
- Add the eggs, vanilla extract, lemon extract, lemon oil, and mix until it forms a soft dough
- Fold in the lemon rind if using then refrigerate the dough for one hour or until firm
- Pre-heat oven to 350 degrees and line your baking sheets with parchment paper or Silpat
- Divide the dough into 30-35 even pieces
- on a lightly floured surface roll each ball into a rope 7″ then pinch the ends together to form a circle. You can also drop the cookies by spoon onto the sheet, braid or roll in a ball and flatten slightly.
- The cookies will puff up so leave 2″ minimum between each cookie and bake for 10-12 minutes or until golden on the bottom. Don’t over-bake. I check after 10 minutes to see what the bottoms look like.
- Remove from the baking sheet to a wire rack to cool completely before icing.
- Lemon Glaze and Sprinkles:
- In a bowl add the confectioner’s sugar, lemon extract, lemon oil and add milk starting with a tablespoon until desired consistency. If you prefer a light glaze add more milk if you prefer thick add less milk. You can always add but you can’t take away.
- Dip the tops of each cookie into the glaze or frost if thicker icing and add coloured sprinkles of your choice immediately after. Let the icing firm before serving if a glaze consistency which is what I did.
- Store in the freezer for up to 6 months in a sealed container with wax paper in between the layers.
- Serve at room temperature with espresso, coffee or your beverage of choice.
We made these Italian Lemon Cookies for Christmas and will make a batch for our Easter dinner with the family next Friday.
I might get a bit fancy and add Easter coloured sprinkles of yellow, pink, green, purple on top or even some candy bunnies depending on what I find at the Bulk Barn.
These are an affordable cookie that is easy to make, soft, fragrant, dunkable and most of all very pretty with the coloured sprinkles.
If you like FREE then click this link for my FREE Excel Budget Spreadsheet and lists.
- Easter Bunny Shortbread Cookies with Lemon Drizzle
- Easter Chick Tarts
- Mars Bars Rice Krispies Easter Treats
- Frugal Easter Traditions We Started As A Family
- Easter Dinner in the Crock-pot
- Italian Potato Donuts Zeppole